How to Convert Your Discretionary Trading System into an Algorithm

In today’s fast-paced markets, successful traders are increasingly turning to algorithmic trading to gain an edge. If you’ve been trading manually with a consistent system, you’re sitting on a valuable asset that could be transformed into an automated strategy. Converting your discretionary trading approach into an algorithm offers numerous benefits: consistent execution, freedom from emotional decisions, and the ability to trade 24/7 without constant monitoring.

However, many traders find this transition challenging. How do you translate intuitive decisions and chart-reading skills into lines of code? This comprehensive guide will walk you through the process of converting your discretionary trading system into a fully functional algorithm that you control.

Analyzing Your Current Trading System

Before writing a single line of code, you need to thoroughly understand your own trading process. Many discretionary traders operate on instinct and experience without explicitly defining all their rules.

Document Every Decision Point

Start by creating an exhaustive list of all the conditions that must be met before you enter or exit a trade:

Market conditions: What broader market environment must exist? (trending, range-bound, volatility thresholds)
Entry triggers: Precisely what conditions signal an entry opportunity?
Exit criteria: What specific conditions lead you to close positions (both winning and losing)?
Position sizing: How do you determine trade size?
Time-based rules: Do you avoid trading during certain periods?

Identify Hidden Rules

Many discretionary traders follow unconscious rules they’ve never explicitly documented. Review your trading journal to identify patterns in your decisions:

Do you trade differently after a series of losses?
Are your best trades concentrated at certain times of day?
Do you perform better in certain market sectors or instruments?
Are there particular price patterns that consistently attract your attention?

For example, you might discover that while you think you trade based on a specific indicator, you actually perform better when that indicator aligns with a particular price pattern.

Quantify Subjective Elements

Discretionary trading often relies on subjective assessments that need concrete definitions for algorithmic implementation:

Discretionary Concept	Algorithmic Definition
“Strong uptrend”	Price above 50 EMA with 20 EMA > 50 EMA and RSI > 60
“Support level”	Price area where previous 3+ swing lows occurred within 0.5% range
“Excessive volatility”	ATR value > 150% of 20-day average ATR
“Bullish engulfing pattern”	Current candle open below prior close AND close above prior open with body size > 1.5× previous candle

The goal is to transform every subjective judgment into a precise, measurable condition that can be programmed.

Need Help Defining Your Trading Strategy?

At Algo Wisdom, we specialize in helping traders transform their discretionary strategies into precise, codable rules.

Explore Our Services

Translating Discretionary Elements into Code-Friendly Rules

Once you’ve documented your trading system, the next step is translating these rules into algorithmic logic.

Chart Patterns to Technical Indicators

Many traders rely on visual patterns that computers can’t directly “see.” Instead, you need to identify the underlying characteristics of these patterns:

Head and Shoulders Pattern: Can be detected using peak and trough analysis with specific measurements between highs and lows
Wedges and Triangles: Identifiable through regression lines and converging trendlines
Candlestick Patterns: Can be detected through relative open/close/high/low relationships

For example, if you trade breakouts from bull flags, your algorithm needs to identify:

A strong upward move (the flagpole)
A period of consolidation with lower highs (the flag)
A volume increase and price breakout above the flag

Replacing Intuition with Metrics

Seasoned traders often cite “feel” or “intuition” about market conditions. These intuitive judgments typically arise from subconscious processing of multiple factors that can be quantified:

“Market feels strong” → Positive advance/decline ratio, increasing volume on up moves, multiple sectors showing strength
“Stock acting weak” → Unable to hold gains, failing at resistance levels, underperforming sector peers
“Getting overextended” → Distance from moving averages, RSI readings, volume patterns

By examining the conditions present when you make these intuitive calls, you can identify the metrics that your subconscious is processing.

Choosing Your Development Approach

Python: The Trader’s Programming Language

Python has emerged as the preferred language for algorithmic trading due to its readability, extensive libraries, and strong community support. For Indian market traders, it offers particular advantages:

Specialized libraries: NSEPy, KiteConnect, and other India-specific packages
Data analysis tools: pandas, NumPy for fast calculations on time series data
Backtesting frameworks: Backtrader, Zipline, PyAlgoTrade
Visualization: matplotlib, plotly for performance analysis
Machine learning capabilities: scikit-learn, TensorFlow for advanced strategy development

Even if you’re not a programmer, Python’s relatively simple syntax makes it approachable for beginners, and the availability of tutorials specific to trading applications makes the learning curve manageable.

Development Environment Setup

A proper development environment will streamline your workflow:

Code editors: Visual Studio Code or PyCharm with Python extensions
Version control: Git for tracking changes and maintaining different strategy versions
Virtual environments: For managing dependencies and ensuring portability
Jupyter notebooks: For strategy research and development with interactive analysis

Building Your Strategy Framework

Creating a well-structured algorithmic trading system involves several key components:

Modular Code Architecture

Organize your code into logical modules:

# Example of modular structure class TradingStrategy: def __init__(self, parameters): # Initialize strategy parameters def check_entry_conditions(self, data): # Evaluate entry logic def check_exit_conditions(self, data, position): # Evaluate exit logic def calculate_position_size(self, capital, risk): # Determine appropriate position size def execute_trades(self, signals): # Send orders to broker

This modular approach makes your code easier to maintain, test, and update.

Implementing Clear Entry and Exit Conditions

Convert your trading rules into explicit conditional statements:

def check_entry_conditions(self, data): # Example of a momentum entry strategy if (data[‘close’].iloc[-1] > data[‘sma_50’].iloc[-1] and data[‘rsi’].iloc[-1] > 50 and data[‘rsi’].iloc[-1] < 70 and data['volume'].iloc[-1] > 1.5 * data[‘volume_avg’].iloc[-1] and self.market_hours_check()): return True return False

Risk Management Implementation

Robust risk management is essential for any trading algorithm:

def calculate_position_size(self, account_value, risk_per_trade, current_price, stop_price): # Risk no more than specified percentage of account max_risk_amount = account_value * risk_per_trade # Calculate risk per share risk_per_share = abs(current_price – stop_price) # Determine position size shares = int(max_risk_amount / risk_per_share) return shares

Let Us Code Your Trading Strategy

Don’t have the time or technical skills to code your own algorithm? Algo Wisdom can convert your trading rules into a fully-functional Python trading system.

Get Your Strategy Coded

Handling Edge Cases

Your algorithm must be prepared for exceptional market conditions:

Market Gaps

def check_for_gaps(self, data): previous_close = data[‘close’].iloc[-2] current_open = data[‘open’].iloc[-1] # If gap is larger than threshold, adjust strategy if abs(current_open – previous_close) / previous_close > self.gap_threshold: return self.gap_handling_strategy()

Technical Failures

Implement robust error handling and redundancy measures:

def send_order(self, order_details): max_attempts = 3 attempt = 0 while attempt < max_attempts: try: response = self.broker_api.place_order(order_details) return response except ConnectionError: attempt += 1 time.sleep(2) # Wait before retry # If all attempts fail, implement fallback plan self.notify_failure("Order placement failed after multiple attempts") return self.emergency_protocol()

Deployment Options

Local Machine Deployment

Running your algorithm on your personal computer gives you maximum control and privacy:

Advantages:

Complete privacy of your strategy
No monthly cloud costs
Direct control over execution

Requirements:

Stable internet connection (ideally with backup)
Uninterruptible power supply (UPS)
Computer that can run continuously
Remote access capability for monitoring

Setup Recommendations:

Dedicated trading computer (not used for other purposes)
Automated startup scripts to resume trading after reboots
Regular system maintenance and updates
Backup data storage

Cloud Deployment

AWS, Azure, or Google Cloud offer reliable alternatives:

Advantages:

Superior uptime and reliability
No dependency on local internet or power
Scalability for multiple strategies
Built-in backup and security features

Implementation:

Set up an EC2 instance (AWS) or equivalent
Configure security groups and access controls
Deploy your Python trading application
Set up monitoring and alerts

Security Best Practices:

Use API keys with restricted permissions
Implement IP whitelisting
Enable multi-factor authentication
Regular security audits and updates

A hybrid approach can offer the best of both worlds: primary execution in the cloud with a local backup system.

Real-Money Testing vs. Paper Trading

While conventional wisdom suggests paper trading first, testing with small amounts of real capital often provides more valuable insights:

Benefits of Small-Capital Testing

Psychological reality: Experience actual gains and losses
Execution accuracy: Encounter real slippage and fill issues
System verification: Confirm all components work together
Commitment: Increased focus when real money is involved

Implementation Approach

Start with 1-5% of your intended full trading capital
Execute your strategy exactly as designed without manual intervention
Run for at least 20-30 trades to collect meaningful data
Analyze execution quality, system reliability, and psychological factors
Gradually increase capital as performance confirms expectations

This approach provides a more realistic assessment than paper trading while limiting financial risk during the testing phase.

Deploy Your Algorithm with Confidence

Algo Wisdom can help you set up your trading algorithm on your local machine or in the AWS cloud, with proper monitoring and safeguards.

Explore Deployment Services

Performance Monitoring and Improvement

Essential Metrics to Track

Set up a dashboard to monitor key performance indicators:

Win/loss ratio
Average profit/loss per trade
Maximum drawdown
Sharpe and Sortino ratios
System uptime and reliability
Execution metrics (slippage, fill rates)

Continuous Improvement Process

Establish a systematic review process:

Weekly review of execution quality
Monthly analysis of strategy performance
Quarterly reassessment of market conditions and strategy adjustments
Maintain separate development environment for testing improvements

Psychological Challenges

Overcoming the Intervention Urge

Many traders struggle with the temptation to override their algorithms:

Establish clear criteria for when manual intervention is permitted
Document every instance of intervention and analyze outcomes
Create a “cooling-off period” before making system changes
Consider keeping trading capital in a separate account with limited access

Building System Trust

Start with strategies you understand thoroughly
Validate extensively with historical and real-market testing
Gradually increase complexity as confidence grows
Maintain detailed logs of system decisions for review

Conclusion

Converting your discretionary trading system into an algorithm represents a significant evolution in your trading journey. While the process requires substantial effort upfront, the long-term benefits include consistency, emotional discipline, and time freedom. By maintaining control through Python development and deploying on platforms you manage, you protect your intellectual property while gaining the advantages of automation.

Remember that successful algorithmic trading is not about removing the human element entirely—it’s about systematizing your best trading practices so they can be applied consistently and objectively. Your expertise and market knowledge are encoded into the algorithm, allowing it to execute your strategy exactly as designed, without the biases and emotions that often undermine trading performance.

Taking the Next Step

If you’re ready to convert your trading strategy into an algorithm but lack the technical expertise or time, Algo Wisdom’s services can help bridge that gap. Our team specializes in translating discretionary trading systems into Python algorithms and providing deployment support for both local and cloud environments.

Whether you need assistance with strategy codification, backtesting, or full system development, we offer end-to-end solutions at competitive rates. Contact us today to discuss how we can help automate your trading strategy while keeping you in complete control of your intellectual property.

Disclaimer: Algorithmic trading involves risk of loss. Past performance of any trading system is not necessarily indicative of future results. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.